Ornamental blacksmith vs Goldsmith

The key difference between an ornamental blacksmith and a goldsmith lies in the materials and scale of their work: ornamental blacksmiths shape artistic metal objects like fences and lamps, while goldsmiths create and repair jewelry and precious metal items.

Both careers require creativity, precision, and craftsmanship, but they differ in the physical demands, typical workplaces, and the specific types of metalwork involved.

Comparison at a glance

Ornamental blacksmithGoldsmith
Education levelMBOMBO
Salary (gross per month, NL)€2,400 – €3,700€2,400 – €3,800
RIASEC codeRAC (Realistic, Artistic)ARI (Artistic, Realistic)
Workplacemixedmixed
Contact with clients or patientslowlow
Physical workhighlow
Analytical workmediummedium
Creativityhighhigh
Typical educationMetaalbewerking (MBO), Siersmeden (MBO)Edelsmid (MBO), Juwelier (MBO), Creatieve technologie (HBO)

What does a Ornamental blacksmith do?

As an ornamental blacksmith, you work with iron and other metals to craft or restore artistic and functional objects such as fences, lamps, gates, and decorative elements for buildings. Your work involves shaping metal using traditional tools like hammers and anvils, often creating complex patterns and designs that require a good eye for detail and artistic skill.

Your daily work is physically demanding, as you handle heavy materials and work in environments where you are exposed to heat and smoke. The workshop setting is common, and you might spend a lot of time standing, bending, and exerting physical effort to shape and assemble metal components.

What does a Goldsmith do?

In contrast, as a goldsmith, your focus is on designing, crafting, and repairing jewelry and other objects made from precious metals such as gold, silver, and platinum. Your work demands fine motor skills and a steady hand to handle delicate materials and intricate designs.

You typically work in a private studio or a specialized workshop where precision and attention to detail are paramount. The environment tends to be cleaner and less physically strenuous compared to an ornamental blacksmith's workshop, as you work with smaller tools and finer materials.

The key differences

  • Ornamental blacksmiths work mainly with heavier metals like iron and steel, while goldsmiths specialize in precious metals such as gold and silver.
  • The physical demands are higher for ornamental blacksmiths due to the size and weight of the materials and the use of heavy tools, whereas goldsmiths perform more delicate, less physically intense tasks.
  • Ornamental blacksmiths often work in workshops exposed to heat and smoke, while goldsmiths usually work in cleaner, more controlled studio environments.
  • The typical RIASEC code for ornamental blacksmiths is Realistic, Artistic, and Conventional (RAC), reflecting a blend of hands-on work and creativity, while goldsmiths have an Artistic, Realistic, and Investigative (ARI) code, highlighting creativity with a focus on fine detail and problem-solving.
  • Salary ranges are similar but goldsmiths tend to have a slightly higher maximum salary, reflecting the value of precious metals and the specialized skills required.

Similarities

  • Both careers require a high level of creativity and artistic skill to design and produce visually appealing objects.
  • Precision and attention to detail are essential in both roles to ensure quality craftsmanship and durability of the finished products.
  • Neither career involves much direct contact with clients or patients, as most of the work is done independently or in small teams within workshops or studios.

Education and route

To become an ornamental blacksmith, you typically follow vocational training in metalworking, such as Metaalbewerking or Siersmeden at the vocational (MBO) level. These programs teach you the techniques for shaping and joining metal, artistic design, and restoration skills.

For goldsmiths, the usual education paths are also at the vocational (MBO) level, including Edelsmid or Juwelier programs. Some goldsmiths pursue applied bachelor's degrees in Creative Technology, which may offer more advanced design and technical skills, especially in modern jewelry making techniques and materials.

Salary

In the Netherlands, ornamental blacksmiths earn between €2,400 and €3,700 gross per month, with an average around €3,050. Goldsmiths have a similar salary range from €2,400 to €3,800 gross per month, with an average of about €3,100. Salaries depend on experience, skill level, and the employer, but overall the pay is comparable between the two professions.

Which career suits you?

Choose to become an ornamental blacksmith if you enjoy working with larger, heavier metals and don't mind physical work that involves heat and manual labor. This career suits you if you like creating artistic and functional objects that are visible in public spaces, and if you appreciate traditional metalworking techniques.

Choose to become a goldsmith if you prefer working with precious metals and crafting small, detailed items like jewelry. This path is better if you want a cleaner, less physically demanding work environment and enjoy fine motor tasks that require a steady hand and patience.

Still unsure? Take the free career test

Frequently asked questions

Do both careers require a lot of creativity?

Yes, both ornamental blacksmiths and goldsmiths need creativity to design unique and appealing objects. While the scale and materials differ, artistic skill is important in both professions.

Is physical strength important for both jobs?

Physical strength is more important for ornamental blacksmiths due to the heavier materials and tools used. Goldsmiths work with smaller, delicate items, so fine motor skills and steadiness are more critical than brute strength.

Can I become a goldsmith with a university degree?

While most goldsmiths train at the vocational level, some pursue applied bachelor's degrees in Creative Technology to gain advanced skills. University-level education is less common but possible for specialized roles in design and technology.

Do both careers involve working with clients directly?

No, both careers involve low levels of direct client contact. Most of the work is done independently or within workshops, focusing on craftsmanship rather than customer interaction.

See also