Singer vs Musician

The key difference between a singer and a musician lies in the primary focus of their craft: singers use their voice as their main instrument to perform songs, while musicians may play various instruments or also use their voice but often engage more broadly with music creation and performance.

Both careers involve performing for audiences, whether live or in recordings, and require creativity, discipline, and technical skill. However, the nature of their work, education paths, and day-to-day activities can differ, which might influence which career suits you better.

Comparison at a glance

SingerMusician
Education levelMBO/HBOMBO/HBO/WO
Salary (gross per month, NL)€2,400 – €4,200€2,400 – €4,500
RIASEC codeAES (Artistic, Enterprising)AES (Artistic, Enterprising)
Workplacemostly on location, partly remote possiblemostly on location, partly remote possible
Contact with clients or patientshighhigh
Physical workmediumlow
Analytical workmediummedium
Creativityhighhigh
Typical educationMuziekopleiding (MBO), Popmuziek (HBO), Vocal Performance (HBO)Muziekopleiding (HBO), Popmuziek (MBO), Compositie en Muziekproductie (WO)

What does a Singer do?

As a singer, you use your voice as your primary instrument to perform songs. This can happen in many settings, such as live concerts, studio recordings, or smaller venues. Your work involves developing good vocal technique, maintaining your voice, and often working on stage presence to connect with your audience. Singers spend time rehearsing, performing, and sometimes traveling for shows, which can lead to irregular working hours. The role demands perseverance, as breaking into the industry and maintaining a career can be challenging. You might also collaborate with other musicians, producers, and sound engineers to deliver the best performance possible.

What does a Musician do?

A musician's role is broader and can include playing instruments, composing, arranging, and performing music. You might specialize in one or more instruments or even use your voice, but the focus is on musical mastery and creativity. Musicians often work in various environments, including live performances, studio sessions, teaching, or composing music. Like singers, musicians face irregular hours and must be disciplined in practice and performance. The variety in activities means you could find yourself teaching students one day, performing on stage the next, or spending hours in a studio perfecting a track. This career requires both technical skill and artistic creativity to succeed.

The key differences

  • Singers primarily use their voice as their instrument, while musicians may play various instruments or also use their voice but with a broader focus on music creation and performance.
  • Education for singers tends to focus on vocal techniques and performance, often through applied bachelor's programs in vocal performance or pop music, whereas musicians might pursue education that includes composition and music production, including university-level studies.
  • Physical work is medium for singers due to the demands of vocal performance and stage presence, while it is generally lower for musicians, especially those focused on composing or playing less physically demanding instruments.
  • Singers often have a more direct connection to audiences through their vocal performance and stage presence, while musicians may engage more with the technical or creative side of music, including teaching and composing.
  • Salary ranges are slightly different, with musicians typically earning a bit more on average, reflecting the broader range of activities and education levels involved.

Similarities

  • Both careers require high creativity and artistic expression, as reflected in their RIASEC codes (Artistic, Enterprising, Social).
  • They both involve irregular working hours, including rehearsals, performances, and travel, depending on projects and gigs.
  • Contact with clients or audiences is high in both roles, whether performing live, recording, or teaching, requiring good communication and interpersonal skills.

Education and route

To become a singer, you can follow several education routes depending on your interests and goals. Vocational training programs focus on foundational vocal techniques and performance skills, preparing you for practical work in the music industry. Applied bachelor's degrees in pop music or vocal performance offer more in-depth training, including stage presence, music theory, and industry knowledge, which can help you build a professional career.

For musicians, education options are broader, reflecting the variety of roles within the field. You might start with vocational training in pop music or pursue an applied bachelor's degree in music performance or composition. University programs in composition and music production are also available, offering a more academic approach that includes music theory, production techniques, and creative development. This wider range of education paths allows you to specialize in performance, composition, or music technology, depending on your interests.

Salary

In the Netherlands, singers typically earn between €2,400 and €4,200 gross per month, with a mid-range salary around €3,300. Musicians have a slightly wider salary range, from €2,400 to €4,500 gross per month, with a mid-range salary near €3,450. These figures reflect the variability in the music industry, where income can depend on experience, specialization, and the types of projects you work on.

Which career suits you?

Choose to become a singer if you are passionate about using your voice as your main instrument, enjoy performing live, and want to develop strong vocal techniques and stage presence. This career suits you if you like connecting directly with audiences through singing and are prepared for the physical demands and irregular hours that come with performing and touring.

Choose to become a musician if you are interested in a broader involvement with music, including playing instruments, composing, producing, or teaching. This career is a good fit if you enjoy technical mastery of music, creativity in different forms, and potentially pursuing higher education at the university level. It also suits you if you want flexibility in how you engage with music beyond just performance.

Still unsure? Take the free career test

Frequently asked questions

Do I need formal education to become a singer or musician?

Formal education is not always required, but it can significantly improve your skills and job prospects. Vocational training and higher education programs provide valuable technical knowledge, performance experience, and industry connections.

Can I combine being a singer and a musician?

Yes, many professionals combine both roles. You can sing and play instruments, compose your own music, or work in various capacities within the music industry. This versatility can open more opportunities.

What are typical working hours for singers and musicians?

Both careers often involve irregular hours, including evenings and weekends for performances, rehearsals, and travel. Flexibility and time management are important to handle these demands.

Is it possible to work remotely as a singer or musician?

Partly yes. While live performances require being on location, activities like recording, composing, and teaching can sometimes be done remotely. However, much of the work still involves in-person collaboration.

See also